Why did God create us if we choose evil?


Question: Why has God allowed mankind to continue since Adam in spite of the evil that has prevailed: wars, murders and other sins. Yet God still creates us. For that matter, why did God create the heavens and the earth in the first place?

 Victor Bunton, via email

Answer: The general speculation as to why God created anything at all is not that he was lonely, but that love is effusive — it pours itself out to share its happiness and joy with others. God, who is love, expansively shares his glory with creation and his joy and love with the human person. Using the image of the “big bang,” we can creatively say that we are living in the ever-expansive explosion of God’s love, going out in every direction and gaining speed as it does.

As to why God allows mankind to continue despite our often cruel sinfulness, it should be recalled that cruel and sinful though we can be, we are also loving, always searching for truth, seeking justice and possessing many other virtues besides. Along with the sinners in our family, there are many saints as well. Add to this the progress we have made technologically and even morally over the millennia. Our earliest years were fierce, brutal and short. But gradually in our conversation with God and in response to his grace, we have come to a greater understanding of what is right, what is good, true and beautiful. We have codified justice into law, accumulated great learning, technology, medicine, sciences and the like. It is true that our own age, like all, has its errors and cruelty. So I would argue that your description of the human family is a bit too negative.

A further insight is that sin exists as a necessary condition of freedom. Since God seeks a relationship of love with us, love, by its nature, cannot be compelled. Hence God permits his children to say no, because without freedom, there cannot be love. God seeks the “yes” of some that he is willing to endure the “no” even of many.

Fear of the Lord

Question: Why does it say in Scripture that we should fear the Lord? If Our Lord is all-forgiving and all loving, why should I fear him?

 Chuck Matthews, via email

Answer: The kind of fear that is counseled in Scripture is not primarily a cringing fear, but a fear rooted in love and a disposition that holds God in awe. 1 John 4:18 says, “There is no fear in love, but perfect love drives out fear because fear has to do with punishment, and so one who fears is not yet perfect in love.” If a cringing fear of punishment is all you have, go with it. But as love matures, we increasingly avoid sin because we love God, and we hold him in awe, and we fear offending him who has been so good to us. And this is what is most fully meant by the “fear of the Lord.”

Your statement, however, that God is all-forgiving and all-loving needs a distinguishing reminder. While we live here on earth, it is a season of grace and mercy for us. God sends us every help to turn away from sin and to turn to him. However, at our death, our decision for God or against what he offers is forever fixed, and God will judge with justice and show no partiality (cf. Rom 2:5-11). As we saw in the question above, God does not force us to love what or who he loves. If we say no to God, we bring a just sentence upon ourselves. Grace and mercy will finally yield to God’s perfect justice. We should all avoid the sin of presumption, which is so common today. God is ultimately serious about needing our “yes” to his will and way.

Two Johns and Pauls?

Question: In the first Eucharistic prayer, why are John and Paul mentioned twice in the list of saints before the consecration?

 Mary Rice, Novi, Michigan

Answer: The John and Paul mentioned in the lists of saints in the Roman Canon are different individuals than the apostles John and Paul mentioned earlier in the same list. According to tradition, John and Paul lived during the fourth century. They were beheaded by order of Julian the Apostate in Rome on June 26, between 361 and 363. Little is known of their lives, but they were honored among the first Roman martyrs mentioned in the canon.

This article comes to you from OSV Newsweekly (Our Sunday Visitor) courtesy of your parish or diocese.


Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


Opening the Word: Resting in Jesus to reveal the Father

Friday, July 3, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley “‘No one knows the Son except the Father, and no one knows the Father except the Son and anyone to whom the Son... Read More

Vatican releases new Directory for Catechesis

Wednesday, July 1, 2020
By: Dr. Joseph White The Pontifical Council for Promoting New Evangelization today announced the release of the new Directory for Catechesis for... Read More

Supreme Court justices have a history of being unpredictable

Monday, June 29, 2020
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion Many were surprised at the U.S. Supreme Court ruling regarding gender identity and employment. It was one more occasion... Read More

Opening the Word: The prophet speaks

Friday, June 26, 2020
By:Timothy P. O'Malley It is natural to develop affection for those closest to us. We share communion, made possible through a history of mutual... Read More

Black Catholic leaders say more integration in the Church is possible — if all are willing to do the work

Wednesday, June 24, 2020
By: Brian Fraga When the Church was born at Pentecost, about 3,000 people “from every nation under heaven” were baptized,” St.... Read More

How do we stay hopeful in times of crises? By focusing on God

Monday, June 22, 2020
By: Deacon Larry Oney The year 2020 is turning out to be a year like no other in recent memory. As Catholic Christians, it is not difficult for us... Read More

Opening the Word: Made for God’s presence

Friday, June 19, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley We have undoubtedly heard well-intentioned souls comfort those who have lost a loved one by saying, “Do not worry,... Read More

Why did God create us if we choose evil?

Wednesday, June 17, 2020
By: Msgr. Charles Pope Question: Why has God allowed mankind to continue since Adam in spite of the evil that has prevailed: wars, murders and... Read More

Racism in America: Separated and unequal

Monday, June 15, 2020
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion Imagine this. Most state governors order the National Guard in their states onto the streets to stop the destruction of... Read More

Opening the Word: A Eucharistic teaching

Friday, June 12, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley Every couple of years, Pew Research releases a report on Catholic belief related to Eucharistic presence.... Read More